What Math Teacher Do My Students Want?

At TMC16 one of the impressive experiences was listening to the keynote speech by Tracy Zager (you can find it here ) and I remember briefly mentioning it in a post soon after the conference. Sadly, I never went back and really dissected my positive feelings about it, but I do know that one of the habits I developed after her speech was to communicate pretty regularly with our elementary school teachers more regularly when I ran across interesting math tidbits. I also know that Tracy has written a well regarded book called Becoming the Math Teacher You Wish You’d Had. I have not read this book (yet!) but the title of the book has been haunting me. I am not speaking with any deep knowledge about the strategies that she is advocating and I may be doing her a disservice, for which I apologize in advance. But as I am sitting here at the beginning of my spring break, I am thinking about what has gone right and what has gone wrong so far, 2/3 of the way through my 2018 – 2019 academic year. I also think about the phrase from Dan Meyer’s TED talk, ‘Be Less Helpful’ and this morning I want to try and wrestle with each of these phrases that are resonating in my head.

I will admit up front that my interpretations of these two phrases are my interpretations. I also need to fill in a little background to explain how I understand Prof. Zager’s phrase. I had two high school teachers who were enormous influences on me. I had the same English teacher, Mrs. Myra Schwerdt, for my junior and senior year. The way her typical class went was this – we came into class, she tossed out a question prompted by our reading assignment from the night before and then she moderated the discussion. Tossing out another question if the conversation ran dry or probing someone on an opinion/interpretation that they made. She was sort of first among equals in these conversations. I never felt that she forced us to interpret anything in any way but I also felt that we better have some backing for what we had to say. In my senior year I took AP Calculus BC from Mr. Barry Felps. A typical day in that class started off with a quick look at a new idea with Mr. Felps offering an example or two of ‘how to’ after explaining some new idea. He would sometimes go over a HW question or two from the recent past (often after his go to joke, we’d ask ‘Mr. Felps, can you do problem #12?’ He’d look at the book and nod while saying ‘Yep’. Still cracks me up a bit thinking about this…) After this, typically 15 – 20 minutes total, he’d say ‘Okay, you have work to do and so do I’ He would sit and we would work with our neighbors and friends. If we got stuck, we’d go ask him but most of the time we felt that we wanted to figure it out ourselves. We also had a study group that would periodically meet on Sundays for a combination of football, pizza, calculus, and physics. So, here I have in my mind what ‘Be Less Helpful’ looks like (to my 17 year old self for sure) and an image of the math teacher I wish I’d had (which, I feel enormously fortunate to say is a math teacher I did have)

Fast forward from 1981 – 1982 academic year to the 2018 – 2019 academic year. This year I am teaching four different classes with pretty different groups of students. I teach Geometry with the text I wrote four years ago to mostly 9th and 10th graders, I teach a Discrete Math elective to mostly seniors, I teach a non-AP Calculus class to a mix of juniors and seniors, and I teach AP Calculus BC to a mix of juniors and seniors (with one brilliant sophomore in the mix) These classes all have different needs and different inherent investments from the students involved.

It is, of course, unfair to generalize too broadly, but I think it is fair to say that the general needs/wants of these classes differ. I try to account for that, but I know that there are some tendencies in my teaching that appear in all four subjects. I ask more than I tell. I redirect questions to other students to get their input. I have student in groups of three facing each other. I randomize these groups so that a group of three is together at most for five classes. I write problem sets that dip into past knowledge and ask some questions for which we have not been explicitly prepared. My quizzes are narrowly focused on recent information and they are weighted less than tests. My tests are all cumulative in nature but they are about 70% focused on what has happened since the last test. I want at least one test question to feel novel, to ask students to put together information in a way that feels new – a problem rather than an exercise, I guess I’d say. We have a test correction policy that we adopted this year (you can read about that here, here,  and here  ) and this policy seems to have helped reduce anxiety a good bit. All of this is to provide a little context into my classroom and my vision of what these phrases ‘Be Less Helpful’ and ‘Becoming the Math teacher You Wish You’d Had’ mean.

What I have struggled with, this year more than in the recent past, is the discrepancy between the math teacher I wish I’d had and the math teacher that my current students wish they had. A good number of my students seem to be happy wth how our classes run. I have posted a number of entries this year about student success. I have received some lovely emails from parents of students in Geometry, some nice remarks passed along from colleagues about students in Calculus Honors, some terrific conversations with students in Discrete Math, and an abundance of energy and creativity from my AP Calculus BC gang. In all four of my classes I feel I am reaching some students and making a positive impact. What concerns me, and what prompts this post, is the fact that a number of students are not buying what I am selling. They are frustrated when I respond to a question with a question. They think it is unfair to have a test question that does not look like something they have explicitly practiced. They feel that I am off loading my responsibility as the teacher when I ask them to work in groups to figure something out instead of lecturing and telling them how to figure it out. I have students across a wide range of abilities and a wide range of reactions to what I am trying to accomplish. It is important that I recognize this and do not simply bask in the glow of the students for whom this approach really clicks. Where I struggle, is trying to reconcile what I think I understand about teaching research, what I understand about NCTM’s recommendations, and what I valued as a student with the discomfort and unhappiness that I see in some of my students. I also struggle with balancing what is clearly working with some students in each subject. I don’t want to lose that energy and motivation that I see in students who value what feels like a different way to experience math. I know that this is not an either/or situation. I have two weeks of spring break to think and reflect. I know that there is a way to reach the frustrated kids without giving up the the facets of my class that are valuable to some of their colleagues (and to me!), I know that there is a balance to be struck between asking kids to step out and feel challenged and making sure that they still feel supported.

I think back to a comment from a student abut 6 years ago. About three weeks into the school year she asked for a personal conference to talk about her struggle in our Honors Calculus class. By the way, struggle for her meant that she had a B average instead of her typical A. She said to me ‘I thought that I needed to learn formulas and how to use them. That isn’t working here.’ She and I had a lovely conversation and in the years since I have run into her dad a number of times. He always tells me how important my class was for his daughter. She has sent me lovely thank you notes updating me on her progress. She is an example of a student I was able to help cross a certain threshold. I want that feeling for all of my students in some way or another and I have solid evidence that this is not happening often enough right now. I have some serious thinking to do.

6 thoughts on “What Math Teacher Do My Students Want?”

  1. Oh this sums up some of my conflicted feelings the last 2 years…and the balance of being the math teacher Ss don’t realize they need/want. I have had some success by asking them to reflect on how they are learning the 8 SMP by what they do and what I do, but there are always some who don’t fully buy in, so I am trying to balance more and use a mix of styles.

    So glad to know I’m not alone in these struggles. I have shed a lot of tears in frustration this year related to this topic.

    1. Anna
      Thanks for dropping by and replying to the post. It is SUCH a challenge to balance what I think is best with what individuals feel that they need. We should be careful not to put our ideas ahead of those of our students, but there are times when we know the long game better than they can, right? The struggle to articulate why certain strategies are better in the long term AND the struggle to enact those strategies efficiently is a real battle.

  2. a) Cannot recommend Tracy’s book enough. It’s a watershed moment in math ed books.
    b) Becoming the Math Teacher You Wish You’d Had. I hadn’t thought before your post how important the subject is in that title. You, the math teacher, who now knows more of the content, has seen the inadequacies of the past methods of instruction, has seen what is possible in learners with understanding.

    I don’t blame the learners here. They are showing good metacognition trying to recognize the characteristic of past teaching that got them to what they think the goal is, good grades.

    You’re obviously making progress, by what you write, by the assessment changes. It is possible to help them use their observational powers to change the goals and help them learn what makes it possible.

    1. John,

      Thanks, as always, for dropping in and sharing some wisdom. One of your remarks really caught my eye – because I know which learners are most frustrated. It is often a group of students who have not seen or felt success as traditionally defined. It almost feels as if some are saying ‘I don’t like math the way it has been, but at least I know what to expect’ I want to believe that a new approach would feel refreshing and be a source of optimism that something can be different this time around, but it seems that the uncertainty of the new is the more powerful force.

  3. This was a very thought-provoking read.

    For me, the issue that comes to mind is speaking in class discussion. I don’t think I ever raised my hand to voluntarily participate in high school, and I would definitely not want to be cold-called or pre-selected to speak in class–I just really didn’t like talking in front of my peers. (And, come to think of it, I almost never participate in PD either–though that’s more due to a philosophy of not wanting the session to run over or take up more time than absolutely necessary… I think??)

    And to this day, my preferred class format is group work/problem session combined with lecture–discussions always annoy me!

    And yet here I am trying to get my classes to discuss math on the daily. Makes me wonder what I’m doing with my life, lol…

    1. Kate

      Thanks for dropping by and sharing your thoughts. The cold call comment really caught my eye. One of the constant comments I get from colleagues who have watched me teach is that they are struck by how often I incorporate student names into class conversation. I reflexively find myself saying things like ‘Kate, is that how you did this?’ or ‘Gram, what do you think of that answer?’ My students have (usually) commented that this makes them feel more engaged, rather than commenting on anxiety about being cold-called to say something. It could be that they are just sparing my feelings, though!

      It is interesting to find yourself in a position where your behavior as a teacher would not have made the student version of you happy, but you are convinced that this teacher behavior is the correct course of action, right?

Leave a Reply to Anna Scholl Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *